China’s one-child policy delivers a girl with three names

Daniel Nelson

Looking rather than listening is the key to enjoying  A Girl Unknown, a moving Chinese coming-of-age story.

Much of the dialogue is sparse, exposition even more limited, but much is shown.

The film is set in the 1990s, the height of China’s draconian one-child policy, which is not mentioned, let alone discussed, but is at the heart of Wang Juan’s troubled life.

One effect of the policy, imposed on a society that already valued sons over daughters, was the rejection/ sale/ murder/ abandonment/ non-registration/ belittling of girls.

Wang Juan starts the film as a happy, lively six-year-old in the countryside and we follow her for difficult years following the sudden shocking traumatising deception that sees her mother hand her over to an unhappily married childless couple. (The three families in the films speak different southern Chinese languages, and Wang has a different name in each, which adds to her dislocation: part of the nuances that may be missed by Western audiences.)

Her new taciturn, depressed dad doesn’t want her around; caring new, educated mum is desperate to nurture a warm bond. But Wang cannot accept what has happened to her: “Your mummy can enroll you.” “She’s not my mom.” The heartbreak is shared.

More tribulations  occur — school bullying, a sexual attack, another move to a new family (with horribly brattish children), a regimented factory job  — and some joys, such as a talent for dancing, a fragmentary, wordless gesture of care from a near wordless stand-in father, himself traumatised by personal tragedy and job loss. 

Wang Juan gets by, but doesn’t cope well. She’s aloof, cannot overcome her original rejection, is unable to share her emotions. She’s alone and unknown.

You may think this sounds like an unbearable watch, but director Zou Jin keeps the story moving, makes characters rounded rather than simply good or bad, and doesn’t preach. She tells an absorbing, revealing story and at the end even offers hope.

Previous
Previous

Two Kenyans fight on for a glimpse of paradise

Next
Next

More a whydunnit than a whodunnit